All talks

How to read

Truth or Christianity Mythology

1h 43m

Christians say Yhwh's name is the sound of breathing, and that the ancient rabbis taught it. No ancient source says that. The claim was assembled in the last thirty years, and this talk uses it to show how a mythology gets made.

Coming up next Commentary replaces what Jesus said

Your place Not started of 1:43:39

Highlights

Summary

Christians now say Yhwh's name is the sound of breathing, and that the ancient rabbis taught it. The talk walks the piece published that week and shows where the claim came from. Lawrence Kushner, a rabbi, printed the full version in 1993. David Abram printed the inhale and exhale split in 1996 and credited modern students of Kabbalah. Rob Bell, a former pastor, had Kushner on a reading list before the film Breathe, and that film carried the claim into churches. The post going around now takes Bell's lines about birth and death, glues them to Abram's split, and calls the result ancient.

The breathing story is there so you can watch a mythology get made while the text sits still. New manuscripts turn up, lost languages get read, and the Rosetta Stone made a dead script readable again. The Dead Sea Scrolls, the Septuagint, and the later Hebrew text do not agree on who Yhwh is. So the question is not how long a belief has been around. The question is what the passage looks like once you have more of the world around it. If you start from their line, "Yhwh is God," you will not let him be the one testing Jesus, even when the scene is built from his own tests.

The Trinity was put together the same way. It just had longer to sit there, so by the time you met it, it already felt old. What Jesus said is gospel, everything else is commentary. The older sources say the name was spoken, by certain people, in certain places. They do not say it was a breath. Read the Gospels again, and check the claim against the text you already have.

Watch next